• Strawberry Whoopie Pies
  • St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake Bar
  • Signature Sugar Cookies

Pastry Shop News

Easter Treat Menu

Hurry, before the Easter Bunny hides all of his sweet Easter treats! Stop by or order up some treats of your ...  

Win One Of Our Gift Certificates for Your Food Donation to Benefit Mama’s Kitchen

Ooh, it's a Raffle to Benefit Mama's Pantry! Bring over to our Betty's Pie Whole location, one or more of the ...  

Join Us for a Valentine’s Evening to Remember!

Sweetheart Plate for Two- $27.50 excludes tax or gratuity An assortment of delectable desserts includes chocolate covered strawberries, special handmade chocolate ...  

Featured Flavors

Cinco de Mayo Mustachio Cupcake

The Mustachio cupcake topped with a sombrero, just in time for Cinco de Mayo. Arriba!

Lemon Pucker

Tart lemon filling baked into our shortbread crust and topped with sweetened whipped cream. Our lemon pie is sure to make ...

Rollie Pollie ™

Get'em while they're HOT! Come in on Saturday mornings, because it the ONLY time they're available. Fresh out of the ...

Signature Sugar Cookies

Our soft and chewy sugar cookie frosted with American buttercream frosting  $3.95