Pies

 

Fresh from scratch crusts and fillings, just like grandma’s. We use all the best ingredients and freshest selections available to create tasty goodness in every bite!

Download our Menu in PDF
Individual Pies  $5.95
*Whole 9inch Pies  $20 to $28
*Whole pies are occasionally available in the shop however not all flavors are available everyday. Please call ahead to special order your pie.

Cherry, Cherry Baby™ Lattice Pie

Sour Michigan cherries baked into the best buttery lattice crust you'll ever have. The classic ...

 

Lemon Pucker

Tart lemon filling baked into our shortbread crust and topped with sweetened whipped cream. Our lemon ...

 

Pecan Pie

Gooey, butterscotchy, and chock full of pecans this pie is baked with a whole lotta' ...

 

Granny’s Apple Crumble™ Pie

There is nothing more American than Apple Pie. That's why we take such pride in ...

 

Key Lime Pie

Fresh squeezed lime juice is "KEY" to our fabulously tangy custard, baked into our homemade ...

 

Mississippi Mud Pie

A southern tradition....with a twist.  Our chocolate shortbread shell is filled with Belgian chocolate pudding,  ...

 

Blackbird Crumble™ Pie

Bursting with berry goodness! Blackberries, blueberries, raspberries baked to perfection in our buttery crumble!

 

Strawberry Rhubarb Lattice Pie

Strawberries and tangy rhubarb in our buttery lattice crust.  Elizabeth's favorite! Whole 9" - $28. Individual 5" ...

 

Peach Lattice Pie

Our seasonal Peach Pie is summer at it's best!  Our southern style Peach Pie is ...

 

Black Bird™ Lattice Pie

Bursting with berry goodness! Blackberries, blueberries, raspberries baked to perfection in our famous buttery crust!

 

Milky Way Pie

Chocolate cookie crust filled with milk chocolate and caramel, topped with chocolate curls.

 

Coconut Cream Pie

Homemade coconut vanilla bean custard, whipped cream topping, sweetened coconut, in our own buttery crust

 

Banana Cream Pie

Vanilla bean custard, fresh bananas in a banana graham cracker crust. Finished with our own ...