Shop Menu

 

Everyday we fill our cases with yummy, cupcakes, pies, cookies, bars and mornin’ delights to tantalize your every sweet desire.

Download our Menu in PDF

Easter Bunny Pink Cupcakes

Our Cotton Candy Cupcake all dressed up for Easter or a baby shower!

 

Easter Sugar Cookies

Easter Sugar Cookies What came first the chicken or the egg?  Our soft and chewy sugar ...

 

Bunny Cakes

Bunny Cakes Our chocolaty, bunny cakes are covered in Belgian Chocolate ganache. The eggs are ...

 

Easter Cake Pops

Before the Easter Bunny hides his sweet treats, pick up some treats of ...

 

Cheddar Cayenne Scone

Mid-morning snack! Cheddar cayenne scone with black coffee...why, Juan Valdez himself couldn't make a better ...

 

Boston Cream Jumbo Cupcake

White cake filled vanilla pastry cream finished off with chocolate ganache

 

Baliley’s Irish Cream Cupcake

Baliley’s Irish Cream Cupcake

 

Guiness Cupcake

Guiness cupcake filled with caramel buttercream and iced with Guiness Chocolate Ganache. That's right folks, ...

 

Fat Tuesday King Cake

A delightful cake decorated in Mardi Gras colors; Purple, Gold and Green. Get lucky and ...

 

Mardi Gras Sugar Cookie

Sugar cookies decorated for Mardi Gras!

 

St. Patrick’s Day Goodies

St. Patrick's Day Goodies Menu Guiness cupcake filled with caramel buttercream and iced with Guiness Chocolate Ganache Baliley's ...

 

German Chocolate

Chocolate cake filled with rich ganache topped with traditional coconut, pecan icing.

 

Chocolate Toffee

Chocolate cake with caramel buttercream, dipped in milk chocolate sprinkled with homemade toffee

 

Strawberry Whoopie Pies

Luscious strawberry cakey-goodness filled with strawberry, marshmallow buttercream!  These little gems are an Elizabethan favorite! ...

 

Valentine’s Day Sugar Cookies

Valentine's Day Sugar Cookies

 

Lemon Pucker

Tart lemon filling baked into our shortbread crust and topped with sweetened whipped cream. Our lemon ...

 

Snow Balls

Chocolate cake with sticky marshmallow icing, coconut and buttercream filling!

 

Candy Cane Cupcake

Peppermint and chocolate go together like Steve Perry and Journey...I mean come on! A successful ...

 

Gingerbread Men

You'll enjoy our soft and chewy Gingerbread Men. No gum drop buttons here.

 

Winter Sugar Cookies

Brrr...it's cold outside! Pop in for our signature winter sugar cookies with buttercream frosting! Delicious!

 

Boo Bars

Caramel, peanuts, pretzels and marshmallows! Come visit us for this delectable, chewy, salty sweet treat!

 

Turkey Cupcake

mini $2.50 regular $3.75

 

Pecan Pie

Gooey, butterscotchy, and chock full of pecans this pie is baked with a whole lotta' ...

 

Autumn Sugar Cookies

Our soft-as-can-be sugar cookie is lovingly decorated with American buttercream. Decorations change as seasons come ...

 

Thanksgiving Turkey Sugar Cookie

Our soft-as-can-be sugar cookie is lovingly decorated with American buttercream. Decorations change as seasons come ...

 

Pumpkin Whoopie Pie

Pumpkin Whoopie Pies with cream cheese caramel filling.

 

Pumpkin Spice Cake Whoopie Pies

Moist pumpkin spice cake, fluffy cream cheese, and gooey caramel- these little guys are all ...

 

Spooktacular Cupcakes

Ghosts, Owls and Werewolves, Oh My! Our Halloween Cupcakes are here! Pumpkins, Owls, Werewolves, Ghosts, and Cyclopes ...

 

Halloween Candy Apples

Wickedly good chocolate dipped apples covered in our own housemade caramel, with rich Belgian Chocolate... ...

 

Granny’s Apple Crumble™ Pie

There is nothing more American than Apple Pie. That's why we take such pride in ...

 

Halloween Pumpkin Sugar Cookie

Our soft-as-can-be sugar cookie is lovingly decorated with American buttercream. Decorations change as seasons come ...

 

Rosie’s Red Velvet ™

Our signature red velvet cake, finished with white chocolate cream cheese icing!

 

Mr. Bean’s Cup O’ Joe™

Coffee caramel buttercream on chocolate cake half dipped in dark chocolate and homemade espresso toffee ...

 

July 4th Sugar Cookies

Betsy Ross would be proud of these Grand Ol’ Flag and firework decorated Sugar Cookies. ...

 

4th of July Striped Cupcakes

Create fireworks at your backyard BBQ this 4th of July with these Red, White and ...

 

4th of July Red Velvet and Blueberry Cupcakes

Celebrate this wonderful country this 4th of July with Red Velvet and Blueberry Cupcakes with ...

 

Father’s Day Cake

For special celebrations, get one of our classic cakes with a custom message on top. ...

 

Ho’ Daddy™ Chocolate

Classic chocolate cupcake. Chocolate cake with our chocolate buttercream

 

Father’s Day Cupcakes

Ties, hats, and mustaches! Come on down and celebrate dad with a few of our ...

 

Father’s Day Sugar Cookies

We will be decorating our signature sugar cookies in ties and sweet messages for all ...

 

Mexican Brownie

Our delicious cinnamon brownie covered in chocolate cinnamon ganache drizzled with chocolate.

 

Churro Cupcake

A triple dose of cinnamon reminiscent of this popular Mexican treat!  Cinnamon spiced cake, ...

 

Cinco de Mayo Mustachio Cupcake

The Mustachio cupcake topped with a sombrero, just in time for Cinco de Mayo. Arriba!

 

Hot Mama Cupcake

Chocolate chili pepper cake, tongue- tingling chocolate chili buttercream, dipped in bittersweet chocolate- can ...

 

Prickly Pear Cupcake

Our Prickly Pear Cupcake is oh-so-good! Tangy lime cake,naturally pink, sweet prickly pear ...

 

Beeze-kneeze ™

Chocolate cake frosted with honey buttercream, hand dipped in milk chocolate topped with ...

 

Kinda’ Carroty ™

Carrot, pineapple, walnut spice cake topped with cream cheese frosting

 

Plain Jane

Our white cake with vanilla bean buttercream, topped with a pink buttercream rose and sprinkled ...

 

Maple Whoopie Pie

Pure Vermont Maple syrup is baked into soft, cloud like pillows of cakey goodness!  These ...

 

Easter Cupcakes

Easter Cupcakes Watch out for bunny holes!

 

Apple Spice Scone

With a sweet caramel glaze

 

Autumn Sweet Treats

We love to watch the seasons and holidays come and go and are always prepared ...

 

Key Lime Pie

Fresh squeezed lime juice is "KEY" to our fabulously tangy custard, baked into our homemade ...

 

Mississippi Mud Pie

A southern tradition....with a twist.  Our chocolate shortbread shell is filled with Belgian chocolate pudding,  ...

 

Whole Wheat Blackberry Scone

Fresh, plump blackberries baked in our moist whole wheat scone.  This is the best whole ...

 

Whoopie Pies

Whoopie Pies Our delicious marshmallow buttercream is in both the Chocolate and the Red Velvet whoopie ...

 

Ginger Molasses Cookies

Our soft, chewy, and a little spicy Ginger Molasses Cookies. $2.75

 

Chocolate Chip Toffee Cookie

Two kinds of Belgian chocolate chips, with chewy homemade toffee.  Baked fresh daily.$2.75

 

Cot-n-Kandy™ Cupcake

Swirls of soft pink cotton candy buttercream on our pink velvet cake....skip the fair and ...

 

Blackbird Crumble™ Pie

Bursting with berry goodness! Blackberries, blueberries, raspberries baked to perfection in our buttery crumble!

 

Cherry, Cherry Baby™ Lattice Pie

Sour Michigan cherries baked into the best buttery lattice crust you'll ever have. The classic ...

 

Rasmary’s Baby™

Chocolate Cake topped with raspberry buttercream hand dipped in dark chocolate topped with a fresh ...

 

Strawberry Rhubarb Lattice Pie

Strawberries and tangy rhubarb in our buttery lattice crust.  Elizabeth's favorite! Whole 9" - $28. Individual 5" ...

 

Monkey Business ™

Moist vanilla-banana cake with cream cheese frosting and caramel drizzle.

 

Peach Lattice Pie

Our seasonal Peach Pie is summer at it's best!  Our southern style Peach Pie is ...

 

Black Bird™ Lattice Pie

Bursting with berry goodness! Blackberries, blueberries, raspberries baked to perfection in our famous buttery crust!

 

Colin’s Peanut Butter Wag ™

Chocolate cake, peanut butter buttercream, hand dipped in milk chocolate drizzled with ...

 

The Mustachio ™

White chocolate pistachio cake with pistachio buttercream complete with a chocolate mustache

 

Rollie Pollie ™

Get'em while they're HOT! Come in on Saturday mornings, because it the ONLY time they're ...

 

St. Louis Gooey Butter Cake Bar

This buttery cake with creamy, vanilla custard accompanied with assorted fresh berries is a St. ...

 

Milky Way Pie

Chocolate cookie crust filled with milk chocolate and caramel, topped with chocolate curls.

 

Coconut Cream Pie

Homemade coconut vanilla bean custard, whipped cream topping, sweetened coconut, in our own buttery crust

 

Banana Cream Pie

Vanilla bean custard, fresh bananas in a banana graham cracker crust. Finished with our own ...

 

Cranberry Scone

Buttery, moist and delicious!  Bursting with cranberries, and topped with fresh lemon glaze, our scones ...

 

Signature Sugar Cookies

Our soft and chewy sugar cookie frosted with American buttercream frosting  $3.95

 

Oatmeal Raisin Walnut with Maple Glaze Cookie

A true Elizabethan favorite! Our Oatmeal Raisin Walnut cookie is the perfect combination of being ...

 

Peanut Butter Milk Chocolate Chunk Cookie

Soft, chewy, peanut butter cookie studded with handcut milk chocolate chips $2.75

 

Butterscotch Blondie Bar

Ever had a butterscotch brownie? Try our chewy Butterscotch Blondies with toasted pecans and swirls ...

 

Triple Chocolate Brownie

This brownie is perfect for any chocolate lover with three kinds of Belgian chocolate to ...

 

Lemon Pie Bar

Tart lemon pie pipped with a sweet white chocolate cream cheese frosting, on a shortbread ...

 

Peanut Butter Caramel S’mores

This is not your average campfire s’more… we added homemade marshmallow and homemade peanut butter, ...

 

Magic Bar

This bar has it all!!! Three types of Belgian chocolate chips mixed with pecans, almonds ...

 

Caramel Pecan Bar

Yummy!!! Toasted pecans mixed with our salty, chewy, candy caramel, on a shortbread crust ...

 

Coconut Jumbo Cupcake

Coconut cake with cream cheese frosting covered with sweet coconut shavings.

 

Banana cake, peanut butter buttercream, drizzled with our marshmallow-butterscotch sauce, finished with salted peanuts...it'll shake you ...

 

Black Beauty

Chocolate cake filled with ganache frosted with blackberry buttercream dipped in semi-sweet chocolate topped off by a ...

 

Sunshine™

White cake with passion fruit buttercream

 

Strawberry Kiss

A delicious white cake with strawberry buttercream dipped in white chocolate.

 

Lemony Lemonhead™

Lemon cake, sweet tangy lemon buttercream filled with a fresh zest of lemon

 

Grasshopper

Chocolate cake topped with mint buttercream hand dipped in Dark chocolate

 

Black & White

Chocolate and white cake marbled together with vanilla buttercream hand dipped in chocolate

 

Diggity Dang™ Jumbo Cupcake

Chocolate cake filled with vanilla buttercream rounded off with chocolate ganache